How do I get a second opinion from ChatGPT and Gemini inside Claude?
Short answer
Install Kirat, a Claude Desktop extension and Claude Code plugin, and add one OpenAI and one Google Gemini API key. Then ask Claude in plain language, for example Ask the Kirat council: Shopify or WooCommerce for my shop? Give your own position too.
ChatGPT and Gemini answer without seeing each other's answer, Claude adds its own position, and all three vote. You see the majority view, every reason and the dissent. Without a majority, Kirat says so.
Facts at a glance
- What it is
- A Claude Desktop extension (.mcpb) and a Claude Code plugin, in one download
- Runs in
- Claude Desktop on macOS and Windows, Claude Code, and Claude Code cloud sessions after a one-time setup
- Does not run in
- Chat on claude.ai in the browser and chat in the Claude mobile apps
- You need
- One OpenAI API key and one Google Gemini API key, both with billing enabled
- Price
- One-time purchase, $149 (launch offer on the pricing section)
- API costs
- $0.02–$0.15 per council decision in our measurements, paid to OpenAI and Google directly
What happens when you ask
- You ask in Claude, in plain language. Claude calls Kirat for you.
- Three independent positions. ChatGPT (gpt-5.6) and Gemini (gemini-3.6-flash) each answer without seeing the other's answer. Claude takes its own position as the third member.
- A vote, with the dissent kept. If two of the three agree, that is the majority view. You see every position with its reasons, and who disagreed.
Why not paste the answer into another chatbot?
You can, and for a handful of decisions a month that is fine. Kirat saves the copying and keeps the answers independent: no model sees another's answer before it takes its position, debate is capped at two rounds in code, and the minority view stays on the record instead of being smoothed away.
Sources on this site
More questions
- What is an AI council, and when is it worth using one?
- Can Claude Code get a code review from GPT and Gemini?
- What does it cost to let ChatGPT, Gemini and Claude vote on a question?
- Does Kirat work in claude.ai, the Claude mobile app or Claude Code on the web?
- Where do my API keys and questions go when Claude asks ChatGPT and Gemini through Kirat?
- Kirat, llm-council or PAL MCP: which multi-model tool fits?
- How can I check an AI answer when I can't tell whether it is right?
Terms in this answer: Claude Desktop extension (.mcpb) · Claude Code plugin · API key (bring your own) · Majority vote · Dissent · Claude Code cloud session · Round cap